Mortise Chisel ERGONOMICS
I have a set of Narex mortise chisels that I'm thinking to upgrade. They have served well. I have no issue with the steel; I don't mortise so often that they require inordinate sharpening.
What I find objectionable is the hoop and the handle. The heel frays and the hoop never fit well; it spins. Is it supposed to? Also the handle is just a little too awkward and doesn't have a good feel when held firm for mallet striking. I feel silly even writing that. How precious!
Anyway, I am considering one of the next-level-up chisels. I am sure they will ALL have good enough steel for me. But the handle styles are markedly different.
The Lie Nielsens appear dainty (as are the bench chisels). Is that handle prone to a mallet slipping when struck?
The Veritas' appear long. I'd figure this would impede the ability to reset the chisel with each strike.
The Ray Iles look like they're very hefty and shorter, which instinctively feels appropriate for this task.
Japanese chisels? I tried Brian Holcombe's and they were wonderful but my success with them might be attributed to HIS having sharpening them. It's a hard world to navigate too.
I don't have ready access to try any of these, so advice is appreciated.