Finish Nailer for Stairway?

Hi Gang:

I have an up coming project to install a new hardwood stairway in our older home and am trying to get my ducks in a row before I start this project. Currently I have a 16ga PC finish (or is it a brad?) nailer and was wondering if this would be sufficient for use on 1" oak stair treads or if I should bite the bullet and get a real 15ga finish nailer for the project?

If it is the case for a new nailer, which one is the best choice; PC, Bostitch or Dewalt or none of the above?

As always, this board seems to be the most civil and helpful and trust your inputs.

mike i have a 15 ga senco angled finish nailer that i've put thousands of nails through without a single jam.a little pricey,but you get what you pay for.good luck with your stairway.

Mike, I have a 16 gauge nailer I use for trim, but I think I'd want a 15 gauge nailer for a stairway. It has a lot more holding power.

15 ga Bostitch - oilless and lots of power and lightweight. Caveat being you need Bostitch 15g angle nails (slightly different angle than other angle nailers) and they only seem to be available in 5000 or so quantity boxes...but I still like mine.

Hi, I just did this and what I did was use four screws with liquid nails to attach the treads. For the risers I used finish nails and liquid nails. I countersunk the screws and wood plugged them. I feel better about using this method as I don't want any squeeks on the treads in the future. I guess whatever method you use with liquid nails should give you a squeek free result. Good luck.

I would use a 15ga nailer as the 16 ga is more like to follow grain in oak.

Rather than use Alan's Liquid Nails, I would try to screw from the bottom of the stairway into the oak to hold it tight to the horses/treads.

Not sure I know what kind of stairs you are building. If it is a box stairs with closed stringers, it should be built to be held together with wedges. If it is open treads you should have lots of glue blocks under the treads and risers. Which ever you are using the 16 ga is fine for tacking together, but like Alan said, go heavy on the PL. A few well placed screws also helps.

Richard

Mike...I have the Senco 15 gauge finish nailer. I've been happy with it's performance.

For a stair treads etc. I think I would go with a 15 Ga nailer instead of 16. But if you don't want an excuse to buy a new gun, I have the 16 ga PC and it will definitely sink them easily in 3/4 oak below the surface, but I think the 15 Ga will be a little better suited for the job.

Corey