When I built out my shop 7 years ago I had a local lighting supply house design a layout and recommend fixtures and bulbs. I ended up with 14 8' commercial grade T12 HO fixtures and F96T12HO/CW/CT bulbs--12 in my shop area which is insulated and kept at at least 42F. and 2 in the storage area which is uninsulated and unheated. The latter are only on when its dark and when I'm in there--they are on a motion detector. They've worked great and the shop is nice and bright.
Fast forward to 2011, the bulbs are starting to get pretty dark on the ends on the ones in the shop so I've been thinking that its getting to be about time to consider re-lamping. Then this week I learned that T12 production is on its way out and it already appears the cost of the lamps has jumped quite a bit from when I bought them. From what I've read, they'll be out of production in a year (July 2012) and I can only imagine what will happen to prices.
I've got three options, I think.
- Buy new lamps now, and I'm considering buying enough to do it twice. That would run me about $350 but probably get me 15 years more service. Sounds like it wouldn't be a bad idea to buy a few ballasts for future repairs too.
- Junk it all and start over. A comparable fixture with 4 T8's runs a little over $100. With lamps I'd be well over $1800 including 2 sets of lamps.
- Reuse the housings with new sockets and ballast covers that would convert them to 4-4' T8's. Looks like those run in the $40-50 range per fixture, plus lamps. It looks like I'd loose about 20% of the light output. Still looking at $1000+ with two sets of lamps.
Looks like the energy savings is about 30% going to T8's I'm thinking for a hobby shop--meaning if the lights are on 10-15 hours per week on average I'd be surprised--that it makes the most sense to stock up on lamps and push out dealing with obsolescence for another 15 years. By then, perhaps LED lighting will be mainstream affordable.
That said, my finishing room is getting T8's!