Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
Results 1 to 15 of 24

Thread: Major checking on walnut - what to do?

  1. #1
    Join Date
    Sep 2011
    Location
    Austin, TX
    Posts
    29

    Question Major checking on walnut - what to do?

    This is from some local (Texas) walnut I picked up about 7 months ago. The ends were painted and it's been in my garage since then. I rough turned the bowl, soaked it in DNA and let it air dry for a few weeks. Mounted it to turn again and this is what I'm seeing... any suggestions on how to manage this? Is the wood salvageable.. should I ignore and just finish turning it? Or is this just the way the walnut cookie crumbles?

    This is the 2nd piece I've had with similar results. I'm using carbide tools for this, would that have anything to do with this?



    photo.jpg

  2. #2
    Those checks are evidence that the wood dried out too fast, either before the rough turning or afterwards. Drying wood in the summer time is difficult, hot dry days cause rapid drying with resulting checks and/or cracks. This piece may be too far gone. I don't believe your tooling is to blame at all.
    _______________________________________
    When failure is not an option
    Mediocre is assured.

  3. #3
    burn baby burn, or time to add some art work, your choice

  4. #4
    I suspect the checks were in the piece when it was roughed. Even though you sealed the ends, the sealer only delays the eventual checking. The pattern of checking in your piece is common on the ends of logs that have been cut a while.

    Typically, when walnut rough outs crack during drying, it will be one or two major splits.

    As to what to do, no recommendation except for 'play it safe'.

  5. #5
    Join Date
    Oct 2009
    Location
    McMinnville, Tennessee
    Posts
    1,040
    Yeap dried to fast. If you are really wanting to save the piece a soaking of thin CA and a light cut to finish may help.


    Sid
    Sid Matheny
    McMinnville, TN

  6. #6
    Also, from my experience 2 weeks after a soak in Dna is not long enough for walnut. Walnut takes forever to fully dry, even after Dna soaking. Here in Kansas, I will have to wait a minimum of 4 weeks and sometimes 6-8 weeks. I also fully wrap my soaked rough outs with 2 layers of newspaper and cut open the bowl opening before sitting it low to the ground in my climate controlled shop.
    -------
    No, it's not thin enough yet.
    -------

  7. #7
    Join Date
    Sep 2011
    Location
    Austin, TX
    Posts
    29
    Awesome replies, thank you everyone. I do have some more walnut from that original haul, I may try rough turning another one and coating it with anchorseal and letting it sit for a year or so. Fortunately I got the wood for next to nothing, so it's not such a big loss with these few. I'll just consider them practice.

  8. #8
    Join Date
    Dec 2009
    Location
    Pauline, South Carolina
    Posts
    88
    When I rough turn green wood, I then soak it in DNA for a couple of days. Next I let DNA flash off for a couple of hours, then coat it with Anchor seal and bag it up in brown paper for a couple of months. Next I will let it sit out in the open for a couple more months before finish turning. This procedure has reduced checking and cracking to minimal. Coming straight out of the DNA to air dry especially in the summer is too much stress on most wood.

  9. #9
    Join Date
    Jun 2009
    Location
    Western Maryland
    Posts
    5,548
    Couple of things, Adam...

    How long did you soak it in DNA? Once you took it out of the DNA, did you wrap it? If so, in what, and can you explain your method? How long did you keep it wrapped? How long did it sit after UNwrapping before you re-turned it?

    How even/consistent is the wall thickness from rim to bottom of your roughout? If your wall thickness varies from rim to bottom (even 1/4" on a small turning like this) the turning will dry unevenly. Though the real problem is when the rim is thinner than the bottom, not vice versa. Make sure that you pay attention to keeping it even. Some people use calipers, some use their fingers. Use what you need to. People keep saying "uneven drying", basically pointing out that parts dried too quickly. While true, we need to find the root of the problem. You see, this cracking could have been from when it was sitting on your floor (and you just didn't turn away the original cracks), or it could have happened after you took it out of the DNA.

    Let us know these things, and maybe we can find out just what happened.
    I drink, therefore I am.

  10. #10
    Join Date
    Sep 2011
    Location
    Austin, TX
    Posts
    29
    Ok, so I'm guilty of not wrapping it after the DNA. I had some decent luck setting some bowls out after the DNA without wrapping them, so I tried my luck and it is probably the cause of the checking.

    This bowl probably sat out for at least a month after the DNA bath, I'm thinking more like 6 weeks.

    The importance of keeping the walls a consistent thickness makes more sense to me now. I don't remember how consistent they were when it was rough turned, the bowl wasn't terribly uneven, but next time I'll try measuring with calipers to ensure it's all the same size. When I roughed the bowl, I don't recall seeing cracks anywhere near the amount I got during the 2nd turning, which leads me to believe it's from the drying process. I do have some more walnut in the garage that hasn't been rough turned yet, so I will see if I can get to some of that this weekend.

    Lessons learned:
    When rouging a bowl, keep the walls at a consistent size
    Post DNA bath - seal/wrap the bowl and be patient

  11. #11
    Those checks are very curious. I've rarely seen them that abundant, shallow, and in that orientation. That bowl is also quartersawn, no? Was the bowl stored upside down, such that the inside was prevented from drying at the same rate as the outside? How thin was the bowl turned?

    Don't DNA it. Just anchorseal it. If you have patience, it's really the easier (to me) way to do it. Also, A Texas garage in the summer isn't probably the best place to let it age. Do you have some place inside that you can keep your roughouts? Huge variation in temp/humidity is your enemy.

    On a quartersawn bowl, you might actually have the best luck just finish turning it green, to a thin, but consistent thickness. It shouldn't move very much at all. I would still let the bowl sit in a paper bag for a week or two to dry enough so you can gently sand it.

  12. #12
    Join Date
    Sep 2011
    Location
    Austin, TX
    Posts
    29
    I do have a crawlspace under my house, it stays much cooler than the garage and may be a good place to store roughed out blanks.

    Bowl was upside down on a high shelf in the corner of the garage. After 2 weeks they were turned right side up and stacked. This was the 2nd bowl with cracks like this, both DNA soaked after a rough turning, then the cracks became apparent after the 2nd turning.

    Quartersawn, yes. The thickness of the bowl now is probably around or a little thicker than 1/2" . I didn't want to go any thinner with all the cracks. I may have enough walnut left to do 2 bowls, I can DNA one and air-dry the other and see if I get the same results. When I have the time, I'll try this and record some more information about the bowls around thickness, time spend trying and so on.

    I'm still a somewhat green turner myself (pun intended) and I have not yet tried turning a green bowl to final thickness. When doing a green to final, should the walls be thinner than when turning a dry bowl?

  13. #13
    Join Date
    Jun 2009
    Location
    Western Maryland
    Posts
    5,548
    Sounds like you have a plan, Adam!

    After taking out of the DNA, wrap the roughout like a present. Then cut the center out of the hollow part of the bowl. That will leave the rim and outside of the bowl covered. Many people like to store the drying bowl upside down on a wire rack. Not sure that is necessary, but certainly doesn't hurt. Leave it like that for at least 2 weeks. Then, unwrap and let sit for another two weeks or so. You ought to be fine, then.

    As far as using the calipers. I don't mean to say that you need to use "measuring" calipers. Rather the ones that have two large arcs. Lock them down on the widest part of the walls, then run them up and down the walls. You'll be able to see where you are "thinner" and by how much (no not by mm's necessarily), but generally. Again, thicker at the rim and thinner at the bottom isn't all bad. Thinner at the rim than at the bottom is a recipe for cracks.

    Enjoy the rest of your walnut!
    I drink, therefore I am.

  14. #14
    Join Date
    Jun 2009
    Location
    Western Maryland
    Posts
    5,548
    Adam, do those cracks go from the outside all the way to the inside? If not, you can turn away the cracks...but the bowl WILL be smaller. Yeah, I know we usually like to just "round" the outside, then take the meat out from the inside...to keep the bowl as big as possible. But if those cracks don't go all the way through, you might be able to turn them away.

    The DNA was not the problem. It was the drying method afterwards that was. But we've already addressed that...
    I drink, therefore I am.

  15. #15
    I think the issue was storing the bowl upside down. The biggest risk of cracks on a qs bowl is about 2/3 the way up on the edge, where the grain forms an oval as the walls go vertical.

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •