Hi everyone,
I just got my Grizzly Christmas catalog and am seriously considering the G1026 3HP shaper for $950 plus shipping. After searching the net for alternatives, my thoughts are to consider the Laguna "compact" 3HP shaper for $2199. It looks suspiciously similar to the Jet 3HP shaper (35X3-1), which is selling for closer to $2800, apart from different color paint.
That said, this machine will be used for home use and will maybe run enough lumber through it to fill a house with furniture if it is lucky (some bookcases, maybe bathroom cabinets etc). I'm not looking at creating mountains of flooring, but may create some floorboards (say 1500' total). The extra $1000 is a lot of money, but I have been given permission by the boss to spend that "if that is what you need". A very loosely defined term that seeks to rely on my potential feelings of guilt if I buy something excessive. Like a $2199 Laguna.
For those of you that already own a shaper, which way would you pull the trigger? The laguna is here: http://www.lagunatools.com/shapers/HD-Shaper_3
I'd gain a more modern design and better dust extraction (not insignificant given I'm working in half a 2 car garage and the wifeys car parks in the other half). Not sure if the flat belt will give me any huge benefits? Quieter maybe or more even torque application? I'm not sure if the Laguna is safer, but it looks to me like the cutters would be more enclosed and less chance for debris flying about.
There is a steel city for sale second hand which I may look at, but it looks very similar in construction to the grizzly - same factory in Taiwan perhaps?
Thanks in advance for any advice you can give this novice / just starting woodworker.
Phil
PS I realize from doing some thread searching that 5HP is recommended, but I'm not sure I can justify the price increase on my limited budget. I'm not in a huge rush so making 2 passes doesn't phase me.