Originally Posted by
Adam Cruea
George> Yes, his sharpening is weird. I can tell you, though, that cutting hickory with a BA saw vs. a LV saw, the BA cuts much faster and much straighter out-of-the-box. The LV saws are nothing to scoff at, the BA are just set better from the box. And you can make the BA saws purdy.
From what I remember, the rake on the LV saws was pretty relaxed; 10 degrees on the carcase saws, and 14 on the dovetail saws. I'd expect most saws to cut much faster out of the box; but I think that's a good compromise assuming a lot of folks new to handsaws are going to be picking them up; if you have someone new to a handsaw pick up something with an aggressive rake, things can get a little jumpy at the start and be tough for someone who's never gone at it before. I know that I can file my saws a lot more aggressive and still get good performance now versus what was pretty touchy for me to start.
" Be willing to make mistakes in your basements, garages, apartments and palaces. I have made many. Your first attempts may be poor. They will not be futile. " - M.S. Bickford, Mouldings In Practice