Page 2 of 3 FirstFirst 123 LastLast
Results 16 to 30 of 32

Thread: I Need Tips for my Talk to a School Shop Class

  1. #16
    Join Date
    Jun 2005
    Location
    Shorewood, WI
    Posts
    897
    Quote Originally Posted by Andrew Joiner View Post

    Shop class experience may not get you a good job but:
    planning and seeing through a project from start to finish is preparation for everything you do for the rest of your life.

    Make connections to other studies where possible: art, history, engineering, physics, chemistry, and particularly math. You don't need to understand all these things to point out the connections and that students may want to keep looking to better understand.

    It's amazing how frequently someone posts a "no math" approach to doing some shop task that looks exactly like what's taught in geometry class. (At least it was when I studied, and had been since Euclid.) Scaling things up or down proportionally, drawing (or cutting) squares, hexagons or octagons the size you want, figuring the radius of an arc given height and width, constructing curves of varying radius that transition smoothly, are all standard parts of geometry that are easier for students to understand if they see why anyone would care. Algebra is about learning how a ruler and numerical calculation can do exactly the same thing as a compass and straightedge, which can lead to simple formulas that are easy to use. Trigonometry adds the protractor to the tool set. Calculus lets you find a "best" solution to many types of problem, once you specify what would be best.

    Just the assertion that math class can show you these things may be enough, if it leads the students to pay attention to their math teachers, and ask them to explain further.

  2. #17
    tell them how it can be fun for them, especially when that yields something useful, the skateboard idea someone mentioned is a great idea
    other ideas would be making a wood-framed electric car for a race, building a transportable shed that can be sold to fund next year's more exciting project etc.

    if the project is reasonable (think school budget and school mindset on safety) and you sell the kids on it, they will sell their teacher on it for next semester, then they will be into woodworking

    Teaching them about tools one by one worked in the 50's when everyone was geared toward this, now kids need more of an immediate perception of future reward to keep their interest.

    I would recommend that you tell them the cool things they can do with woodworking in the time you have, then let them ask you back before you show them all the hard work that is necessary to get there. If they ask you back, they will be ready for the hard work by that point, then they will actually listen to what you have to say.

  3. #18
    My shop class experience didn't get me a job but it gave me a life long hobby. I always loved shop class and took every one that I could fit into my schedule, even though I knew I was going to go to a four year college and get an engineering degree.

    I was very lucky in that my high school had an excellent shop program. We actually had a building construction class where we built a house on piers outside of the high school. At the end of the year this house was then auctioned off by silent auction, and picked up and moved to the winning bidders site. Everytime I went by the high school as a kid and saw this house it fascinated me and I knew it was something I wanted to when I was in high school.

    So even though I knew I'm not in a job in the trades I have a ton of knowledge I can apply to my life. When I have someone builds me a house I will know what it is suppose to look like and can tell if they are doing things correctly. I have the knowledge to complete my own home improvement projects and save myself some money and not have it turn into some DIY nightmare.

    It saddens me to see shop classes thought of as just for people who are going to get into the trades. Everyone should be required to learn some of this stuff.

  4. #19
    Join Date
    Sep 2012
    Location
    Mnts.of Va.
    Posts
    615
    It's practically impossible these days to...."sell a notion or idea".As technology and our reliance on it grows,the mind's ability to visualize shrinks.A simple conversation or brainstorming is becoming a thing of the past.So,going along with Mel in post #12........all safety applied,the more hand's on the better.Try getting them to plane off a long,continuous shaving with a benchplane.See if they can tell the difference between having it dead straight with the part(board)...and having the plane,skewed a bit.Then start describing exactly how the mechanics of the plane work.There is nothing technology related,that can compare with this....so,don't bother trying to convince them.

    I find it very difficult with a lot of younger folks to get them "engaged".......and that isn't a slight on today's youth,they are the future.Best of luck.

  5. #20
    Join Date
    Feb 2003
    Location
    McKean, PA
    Posts
    15,593
    Blog Entries
    1
    I took shop classes in high school and learned the basics of joinery and finishing. I took those basic skills and started making things that we wanted but couldn't afford. The more things I made, the more I learned. I learn something on every project I make. Remember it isn't the quality of the tools, it is the skill of the craftsman using them that makes a project successful.
    Lee Schierer
    USNA '71
    Go Navy!

    My advice, comments and suggestions are free, but it costs money to run the site. If you found something of value here please give a little something back by becoming a contributor! Please Contribute

  6. #21
    Join Date
    Sep 2009
    Location
    Atlanta, GA
    Posts
    6,392
    Bullet points [many already stated in one way or another]
    > Planning skills
    > Organizational skills
    > Analytical / problem solving skills
    > Applied mathematics

    If you can learn woodworking then, by definition, you have advanced your competence in all of these areas. All of these are important skills in the job market, regardless of the industry.

    And - as a benefit - you have something tangible to see when you are done.

    And - Hey - get real - Moms and GrandMoms love stuff you make as presents. Be a hero. They will keep it for their lifetimes, and then, eventually, ti will circle back to you. Trust me - I just cleaned out my parents last apartment [they moved into hospital-style health care center 4 weeks ago.]
    When I started woodworking, I didn't know squat. I have progressed in 30 years - now I do know squat.

  7. #22
    Join Date
    Mar 2010
    Location
    Franklin, Tennessee
    Posts
    348
    Quote Originally Posted by Andrew Joiner View Post
    I got invited to share my experiences as a professional woodworker with my grandson's shop class... The students and the teacher need inspiration.
    As a life-long manufacturing engineer that recently transitioned into the world of high school teaching, I have some recent experience with dealing with the high-school teenager.

    As I read all of the excellent advice in the posts above, the first thing that comes to mind is: What does the customer (the students) need? If you don't meet their needs (expressed or unexpressed) they will perceive you as unnecessary. They will probably be polite, but won't learn a thing, since they can tune out in (literally) nanoseconds.

    Is this a high-school or a middle-school shop class? Are they experienced (2nd or 3rd year) or are they only a few weeks into their shop journey? Knowing just these small facts will go a long way toward understanding their needs, which is the gateway to an interesting experience for them.

    If they are complete newbies, then showing some interesting final products, with a brief explanation of the skills they will need to make the products may impress them. More experienced students may appreciate some pointers for moving beyond the dead-simple.

    Middle school students will have almost no interest in what kind of a job this may lead to... that is so far off in their future (or so they think) that you might as well be discussing the different options for assisted living facilities.

    High school students are (for the most part) interested in college. (It is truly a tragedy of our times that trades are so under-stressed in our high schools, but that is a topic for a different thread). If you can show them the practical aspects (many of which are covered in the comments above) that working with your hands gives you, and how that will help them get into and succeed in college, you will have their attention. Particularly for the students who do not have the 4.0 GPA and 36 on the ACT, stress that emphasizing their abilities to design, plan, and especially to THINK will look terrific on their college application, and may even give them something to write about in their application essays.

    Bottom line: Figure out what they need & what they are interested in, and then give it to them. I'm sure you will do great!

  8. #23
    Join Date
    Jul 2005
    Location
    Eastern Iowa
    Posts
    751
    Quote Originally Posted by Andrew Joiner View Post
    The students and the teacher need inspiration.

    Of course the fact is there isn't a lot of good woodworking jobs. ............
    Shop class experience may not get you a good job but :
    If they are looking for inspiration, the last couple of sentences won't cut it. Instead, be truthful but not negative. Inspire them to be one of those craftsmen that ARE sought out.

    "Woodworking is a vocation that demands pride in detail. As your skills improve your eye for detail improves.
    Pride and detail. That is what people want when they seek out a craftsman to do that special project; whether it be building a house or putting in a new door, building a fine china cabinet or making a bandsaw jewelry box.

    Woodworking helps to develop those skills better than a lot of other activities. You can see the effects of your work habits both immediately and later in a project. 'That cut is kinda square', then when attempting to assemble it you wonder why it doesn't fit right. Woodworking is a great evaluator of how much pride you have in your work."

    Think of the qualities that made YOU successful; relate how they show up in YOUR woodworking. Bring samples/pics of your work. Point out what you do to make it special.

    Above all be passionate about woodworking. Kids, from elementary school on up can tell if you like what you're doing or not. It is darn near impossible for a student to not be interested in a topic if the teacher exudes passion. The converse is also true... Kids can tell. Smile a lot, use inflection. And as for technique, practice in front of a mirror, including emotion (maybe now a days in front of your iPad or phone would be better).
    Last edited by Charlie Velasquez; 10-12-2014 at 8:43 AM.
    Comments made here are my own and, according to my children, do not reflect the opinions of any other person... anywhere, anytime.

  9. #24
    Join Date
    Dec 2005
    Location
    West Lafayette, IN
    Posts
    6,529
    Might be nice for the OP to chime in and respond to the advice given so far.

  10. #25
    Join Date
    Nov 2006
    Location
    NE Ohio
    Posts
    6,983
    Shop class experience may not get you a good job but :
    It gave me a good reference as to what's good and what's not so good.

    Go to a furniture store sometime where all the pressed wood - held together by staples - "picture of wood on vinyl contact paper" sides - has some kind of "mystery wood" that grows on the Asian continent for the "real wood" parts - and soft close Blume drawer slides on the dove tailed drawers.
    hang around and listen to the number of people that open the drawer & pronounce it "quality furniture" because the drawers are dove tailed.


    I'm serious as a heart attack about this. I hear this all the time @ Lowes and HD from people in their kitchen department - both shoppers and the people that work there!
    My granddad always said, :As one door closes, another opens".
    Wonderful man, terrible cabinet maker...

  11. #26
    Join Date
    Nov 2008
    Location
    Northern Oregon
    Posts
    1,820
    Thanks for all the replies.
    So many angles of approaching this, kinda like designing a good chair. If it looks good but it's not comfortable few people want it.
    I have been invited to tell my story and help teach. I'll get my toes wet on the story part first to see if it's a good fit before I volunteer much teaching time.
    My favorite teacher of all time was not a shop teacher but Social Studies. He used humor to get and keep our attention. Humor will be a tool I'll use too.

    I'm optimistic about the opportunities here. I've thought for years I'm so out of touch with kids. Then one day I showed some 40 year old images of my work that popped up on a website to my 15 year old grandson and 18 year old nephew. They know I was a cabinetmaker and love my current work, but had only vague career plans. When I explained the how and why of the 40 year old work process they got very excited. Both saying I want to do that for a living!
    "Whether you think you can, or you think you can’t - you’re right."
    - Henry Ford

  12. #27
    Quote Originally Posted by Andrew Joiner View Post
    Shop class experience may not get you a good job but :
    ...watching Timmy cut his thumb off on the bandsaw is going to give you a story that will last a lifetime!"

  13. #28
    hi:

    Some suggesions:

    1 - remember that the teacher who invited you is probably happy to have you fill the time, but worried that you'll say or do something that reflects poorly on him (or her).

    2 - remember that the class is not homogenous. A few are there to learn but most are there for other reasons ranging from parental presure to an inability to make it in classes where reading is required.

    3 - therefore.. I'd suggest you plan your talk in segments: one for each major sub-group in the class. As a corolary, be aware that the people you're really not talking to at any point will grow increasingly restive. To beat that, bring along some exhibits that can be passed hand to hand among the disengaged.

    4 - tailor your talk to work towards a hands-on demo, encouraging those who want to learn to work with you at it - that way the regular teacher can take over the bored after your alloted tim expires, but those students who are genuinely interested can hang around and ask questions.

    5 - I would not talk about beauty in wood, professonalism, or the application of math to design and execution - those things will cause eye rolling. Just talk about stuff you've done, and customer reaction to it. Most people, including many among the most disaffected, love to hear about other people - so tell them what Mrs jones said that made either no sense or more of it than you understood etc. Stories that include the phrase "as it turned out, however" usually resonant. Then show them how to actually do stuff - the what doesn't really matter: whether your plane a plank or build a three story birdhouse, the message is the same: anything worth doing, is worth doing right and your satisfaction comes from doing it right.

  14. #29
    Quote Originally Posted by Keith Weber View Post
    ...watching Timmy cut his thumb off on the bandsaw is going to give you a story that will last a lifetime!"
    This happened in my 10th grade shop class. Except, the kids name was Chad. I'll never forget watching the humongous instructor slowly lumber on over and ask, "Watcha got there, buddy?" Poor Chad was in such a state of shock, he couldn't even answer.

  15. #30
    Join Date
    Nov 2008
    Location
    Northern Oregon
    Posts
    1,820
    I just got back from my shop class presentation. It went really well. Several kids asked good questions indicating they listened and were interested.

    First off I had a minor confrontation with a typical smart a-- kid named Mike. I know them because I was one! When he learned I was there to tell my story about being a cabinetmaker he said "What, we don't get to work in the shop today". I said maybe not. He said "that sucks". I said you don't get to talk to me like that. He glared at me as I started my talk. After 20 minutes I ended the talk with this question. What's your favorite or least favorite part of woodworking here? Mike raised his hand and I called on him. He said "the table saw is scary".

    We went over and looked at the classic Powermatic Model 72. The teacher said Mike had a kickback recently so no one would go near the saw. The teacher has little experience in woodworking. I showed her the fence needed adjustment to toe it out. Also with no outfeed table any stock over 3' long tipped. After a 5 minute technique explanation and a few test cuts everyone was smiling, including Mike. When class was over I shook Mike's hand and said thanks for bringing up the saw issues. He looked me in the eye and said "thanks for coming". What a rewarding day!
    "Whether you think you can, or you think you can’t - you’re right."
    - Henry Ford

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •