Page 2 of 2 FirstFirst 12
Results 16 to 30 of 30

Thread: Waterlox bubbles and pitting

  1. #16
    Quote Originally Posted by matt romanowski View Post
    I am having the same problems as you for the last week. I didn't try thinning at all today and think I found out what is going on. I believe the bubbles are from solvent popping. That is when the solvent starts to evaporate in the middle of the film but can not get out because the surface has already evaporated. I'm guessing your in the Northern part of the country where the humidity is pretty low right now?
    In Canada, 35% humidity indoors and 71F.

    I'll try the wipe ons.

  2. #17
    After letting the first wiped coat dry for 24 hours, it looked pretty good with a few spots that were matte instead of the gloss(ier). I did a second wipe on coat this morning and it looks perfect. I used half a rag from a Scott box (disposable rags) and put the Waterlox on about half as heavy as the foam brush put it on. It took a little bit of technique, similar to what was posted in the sticky video about using a brush and dragging it. Don't be afraid to work go over spots a few times if they aren't looking how you want. With the large amount of oil, I don't think you have to worry about messing things up.

    Also, working this morning I saw some spots like you showed that appear to be fisheyes. I think they are small drops of finish hitting the surface. I noticed some yesterday and was able to recreate it today. Any tiny drop landing on the finished surface would cause a similar mark.

    I hope this helps you out. I know I was really frustrated until I got these results. I can imagine you are more frustrated that me as you've been at it longer.
    Attached Images Attached Images

  3. #18
    Tried a few things yesterday based on the comments here. First, I'm fairly convinced now I'm getting both fisheye and solvent popping. Fisheye I'm suspecting wax/silicone contamination, but there's nothing environmental, which leaves contamination from the process, candidates would be sanding paper, pads, rags, towels and mineral sprits.

    So I tried on a number of the pieces different techniques, none of which solved the fisheyes. Switched out the rags for scott blue towels, switched out mineral spirits for cleaning the surface with DNA and tried not sanding.

    For the solvent popping/fisheyes, I tried applying as a wipeon with the dennys method and blue shop towels folded into 4 with tipping off by dragging towel lightly in direction of grain, fisheyes and bubbles developed sooner (within 5 mins), although the fisheyes were smaller in size than usual. Tipping off a 2nd time reduced the problem, then bubbles and fisheyes appear again within a few minutes (the fisheyes appear in different locations).

    Then I tried the wipe on, followed by a number of "dry brushes" during drying with a dry blue shop towel dragged lightly. Smoothes over the bubbles and fisheyes, but they appear again shortly.
    (This also indicates I'm not dropping product on the surface causing the fisheyes, because the dragged towel is dry).

    I've only had one success, one of the pieces I wiped on using dennys, but didn't tip off, then cut a maroon 3m pad smaller and sanded the WL in the direction of the grain (i.e. wet sanding with waterlox). Finally tipping off by a light dragging off the maroon pad in the direction of the grain overlapping drags by half the pad width. Finally, no fisheyes. But surface is lined, kinda matte like (which is the ultimate goal, although I'll take anything at the moment, gloss, normal or satin). Not sure if there is any solvent popping still, as the surface isn't glossy enough to see it.
    The next approach I'm going to try here is a "paint pad" coat to see if the fisheye/solvent popping is still an issue over this new layer. If it is, wipe off before dry and sand in with a finer 3M pad.

    I'll grab some Xylene today and try that on one of the pieces.

    It seems to me that WL VOC Compliant doesn't seem to like to bond to WL VOC Compliant which causes these fisheyes.

  4. #19
    Join Date
    Dec 2010
    Location
    WNY
    Posts
    9,647
    Quote Originally Posted by Jim Clelland View Post
    Take the finish back to bare wood, or sand level; xylene,sealcoat then WL. I.E. If Shellac on top of waterlox okay?

    Dewaxed shellac sticks to most anything. Nearly any finish will stick to shellac. Your best approach would be strip off everything and start fresh but if you aren't up for that, which wouldn't take long with KleanStrip Premium stripper, then the approach I outlined above should work fine.

    It sure sounds like you have silicone contamination, courtesy of Ikea. The only surefire way to deal with that is to remove it (Xylene) and seal in any that is still there (Sealcoat).

    John

  5. #20
    Join Date
    Jan 2010
    Location
    Tampa Bay, FL
    Posts
    3,895
    I have my own collection of horror stories with VOC compliant Waterlox. The original Sealer/Finish, on the other hand works great.

    Sounds like both fisheye and solvent popping.

    I would sand down to the wood, and go with the Original Formula. Wipe it on. Much more foolproof. I'd avoid the dry brushing. I can only see that making things worse.
    - After I ask a stranger if I can pet their dog and they say yes, I like to respond, "I'll keep that in mind" and walk off
    - It's above my pay grade. Mongo only pawn in game of life.

  6. #21
    Join Date
    Mar 2007
    Location
    Kingston, ON, Canada
    Posts
    223
    I'd have to agree with those suggesting the finish is drying on the top first (which, incidentally is logical as it's exposed to the ambient air, as compared the the rest of the coat you've laid down) and causing the havoc. However, I wouldn't rule out contaminants in the finish itself. I use mostly waterborne products, and filter the finish before it goes into my gun. Perhaps if nothing else works you could try filtering it before application?
    Marty Schlosser
    Kingston, ON, Canada
    Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/apexwoodworks/
    Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/ApexWoodworksFurniture/
    YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCkmbvXb44CJ9t17SbHEWxJg/videos

  7. #22
    Tried taking it back to the wood, using cleaning with Xylene and applying 2 coats of shellac. Still getting fisheyes, now on the first coat as the Shellac has sealed the wood.
    Here's the exact process followed. So I guess this rules out contamination of the surface by Ikea. Any other ideas?

    1. Took finish back to bear wood with 120 grit, sanded to 220 grit

    2. Cleaned with xylene wiping off any contaminants with Scott Blue Paper Towel soaked in Xylene
    3. Left to Dry (1hr)
    4. Applied Zinsser SealCoat with High Density Foam Brush, areas that soaked up were covered till uniformly glossy
    5. Left 1hr to dry
    6. Sanded lightly with 320 (non stearate) in direction of grain
    7. Wiped off with Scott Blue Paper Towel (no solvent) and Clean hand
    8. Apply Zinsser SealCoat with High Density Foam Brush
    9. Left 2 hrs to dry
    10. Sanded lightly with 320
    11. Wiped off with Scott Blue Paper Towel (no solvent) and Clean hand
    12. Applied VOC Compliant Waterlox (unthinned) with High Density Foam Brush, and tipped off, coat is uniform
    (Waterlox is clean and straight out of the Can into a container)
    13. Fisheyes began to appear after 2 mins
    14. Tipped off again to remove fisheyes
    15. Fisheyes began to appear after 2 mins

  8. #23
    Join Date
    Jan 2010
    Location
    Tampa Bay, FL
    Posts
    3,895
    Wow. Certainly qualifies as the college try, Jim.

    Not sure what to add here. I might have done a few things differently (sprayed a very light coat of shellac to ensure coverage of potentially contaminated areas, not allowing the difference in surface tension to cause the shellac to not cover spots), used Original Waterlox instead of VOC compliant), but I really can't criticize any of your approach or understand where the contamination causing the fisheyes is coming from.
    - After I ask a stranger if I can pet their dog and they say yes, I like to respond, "I'll keep that in mind" and walk off
    - It's above my pay grade. Mongo only pawn in game of life.

  9. #24
    I am with Alan. Try the original formulation

  10. #25
    Quote Originally Posted by Prashun Patel View Post
    I am with Alan. Try the original formulation
    That would be ideal. However where I'm located, it's not available for sale in Original (non low voc). Plus I can't even import it, not allowed by law to purchase or import it.
    Unfortunately I have no option but to use the low VOC.

    Is anybody successfully using the Low VOC formulation without finishing issues? Seems WL claim it works as well if not better on their website, but most people seem to have more success with the original and have abandoned Low VOC.

  11. #26
    Just to update this thread. Shellac on a kitchen countertop under waterlox, bad idea. Shellac melts at 80C, and even with a cork mat down, anything hot melts the shellac underneath and the waterlox delaminates. (Anyway shellac doesn't solve the bubbling on the surface either). It's not silicone or wax contamination (ruled out those), and it's not humudity (tried both in low humidity and higher humidity).

    Also, anything heavy say a gallon of water on a cork mat for a few days and the cork marks the waterlox permanently, even after 3 months of drying.

    End conclusion, if you want something that is practical in a kitchen and looks good when you're done, Waterlox is not it. I've spent over $800 on it and it looks like crap. This is the Low VOC, Original maybe better, I dunno, can't get that here because it's illegal to sell it. I've applied varnishes, bar top epoxies, shellac's, french polish and never had the issues I've had with this product. If you're considering using Waterlox for a kitchen countertop, run now whilst you have the chance and don't look back, if you're considering using it for another project and want something that's durable, wearable and has a good smooth surface, consider something else.

  12. #27
    Join Date
    Jan 2016
    Location
    Longmont, CO
    Posts
    810
    Jim:

    not to counter you. Horrible experience all around and very interesting to some, as we have had great luck with WaterLox. Our maple/walnut/long leaf pine bowling ally island takes a beating and looks great. What did you finally do for your countertop?

    We used the low voc formula.

  13. #28
    Quote Originally Posted by Adam Herman View Post
    Jim:
    What did you finally do for your countertop?
    Currently I have 2 of the 4 countertops with melted marks due to shellac used underneath where hot water was split and melted the shellac (followed the recommendations to try shellac on this forum).
    The other 2 I already re-did and have only waterlox, and one of those marked today from cork pads and some weight for a couple of days (no heat). Weight was a gallon of water distributed over 4 x 8 inch diameter 3/8 inch cork pads (the type typically used for pans). All of the counter tops have been refinished about 5 times by now, everything failed and finish looks like crap. Final iteration was everything sanded out to bare wood, xylene, dennys blue towel technique, 8 coats, 24 hours between coats, Pure Stoddard Solvent wipe and dry between coats and light scotch Fine pad and wait 24 hours and solvent wipe prior to final coat. Nothing solved the dry spots that appeared, just decided to live with them. Tried a variety of application tehcniques, pads, brushes.

    Going forward, I'll be stripping everything back to wood again and then likely epoxy on top.

  14. #29
    Join Date
    Jan 2016
    Location
    Longmont, CO
    Posts
    810
    we have epoxied concrete for the rest of our kitchen, and it took about 3 months for the epoxy to fully cure. just an fyi. Not sure what brand it was, as someone else put it in. my french press left dents where the metal feet got warm and I pushed the plunger down every morning.

  15. #30
    I had similar problems when i was doing my vanity top. bubble or other wierd things in the surface. the issue i think is i was putting it on too thick and i did not get ALL of the dust off the piece before i started finishing it. my solution was after the 3rd coat or so was totally dry, i sanded it pretty good with 1k grit and the subsequent coats i wiped on with a lint free shop rag instead of brushing on with a foam brush. it filled everything and looks great now. cant even tell there was imperfections before. in my experience its best to not go thick. the first coat i keep wiping on and applying untill the wood soaks up most of the varnish. there will be areas that are tackier because they didnt soak up as much varnish. the ones spots that keep soaking it up i pay special attention to until they stop soaking up as much. but like i said the last 3 or 4 coats should be wiped on with a rag and thinly. no sanding between final coats..

Tags for this Thread

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •