So... I've got a few conventional back saws that I picked up either via yard sales, given by friends who'd inherited them, etc. One Craftsman, with miter box (looks like probably made by Miller Falls). Two Disston - one huge beast, maybe 24" long x 6" tall plate, and one smaller one, maybe 14".
Condition as they came to me was poor / dull (except the Craftsman, which was just dull). I was going to send one or more off to Bad Axe Toolworks to get sharpened, but then found a local sharpener and figured I'd give them a try.
Maybe I'm doing something wrong... to my unrefined senses the saws 'feel' sharp - the teeth feel sharp to the touch - but trying to get them started cutting is a bear. Like trying to pull start a chainsaw by dragging it over a log! Maybe I've been spoiled using cheap Japanese style ryoba saws from the big box stores, but once these back saws get started, they're slow to cut and leave a huge kerf. Even trying to pull the saw back to get it started causes it to skitter all over, chewing up the board.
I'm starting to wonder if its just me, or if the sharpening job(s) wasn't as good as I'd hoped?
...and on the flip side, I've been having fits using the rip teeth on the ryoba saws I have. I recently got a new Gyokucho ryoba and dozuki for my birthday. Years ago, I received a rip dozuki as a gift, but hadn't used it til now. The dozukis I have no problem getting started cutting, and they cut fast and precise. I'd hoped the Gyokucho ryoba would be a little nicer than the Irwin pull saw I have in the home carpentry tool bucket, and it is. The crosscut teeth start and cut easy - not *quite* as easy as the dozuki, but close. The rip teeth are still confounding me. Even if I get the cut started with the crosscut teeth, and the then flip the saw over and use the finer tpi teeth near the base (as seen in a few videos) it still balks at cutting, and when it does, its rough and uncontrolled, and if I stop its hell getting started again. Not working with anything exotic here just yet... just relatively clear 1x pine.
Having problems on both fronts makes me wonder if its just a defective Indian, not the arrow(s), but I'm not sure where to start narrowing things down.