Originally Posted by
Mike Holbrook
I think Hard Maple will work Ken. I believe the teeth on mine were a little thin and made from Sycamore, which grows faster and softer. When I get bored I stand in the backyard and watch the Poplars and Sycamores grow. It is always a race to see which can grow the fastest.
I think the design Tom used came from a Brin Boggs design that won a Fine Woodworking design award about 26 years ago. Lie-Nielsen actually use to sell Brian's design or one he or LN had made. Brian's design was a redesign of the old English " Bodger's Bench". Drew's original design in “The Chairmaker’s Workshop” was a German “Dumb Head” design, made from parts split from a log and dried in one of his kilns. The problem with Drew’s original design being that few people will split and dry their own wood. Brian’s design incorporates dimensioned or construction lumber which is certainly more readily available.
Drew mentions in his book: “In fact, workbenches with a screw vise were not commonly found in many workshops until the mid-nineteenth century”. He is talking chair and furniture making workshops, back when many people made their own. It is interesting to consider whether the Shaving-Horse or Bodger’s Bench may have been a more common feature in workshops in that period than Workbenches or at least Workbenches with a vise. Certainly a bench takes up less room than a worktable/workbench. Could the Shaving Horse be the original woodworking vise? Certainly the tools used for making chairs and other furniture then were relatively crude hand tools by todays standard.