Modifying a Spindle Gouge?

[Fred Conte]

Would there be any problems if I ground a 1" spindle gouge to a 1" bowl gouge?

Any comments or recommendations would be appreciated!

Thank you,

Fred

[Kevin McPeek]

It really doesn't work that way. The difference is not just the shape of the end.
If it is a spindle roughing gouge (looks like a big U) I would not recommend using it on a bowl ever. The tang can snap off and cause bodily harm. A spindle gouge that is made from round bar can be used on a bowl in some cases though.
The long and the short of it is- if you want a bowl gouge get a bowl gouge. Trying to use the wrong tool will just be frustrating and sometimes dangerous.

[Fred Conte]

Thanks Kevin, that was my concern - safety - I realize the cross sections were different - just an idea I was thinking about...

[robert hainstock]

I ground the end of a 1 in spindle gauge straight across, Nd use it as a roughing gauge on spindle work. I will NOT use it on a Bowl.
Bob