Hi Everyone. Reading posts on this forum really helped me with my first three finishing projects. I still feel like a novice, so for this next one, I thought I'd actually register and ask for some input.
I have a Danish modern computer desk with metal T-legs that I'd like to upgrade. I would like to remove the top of the desk, which is light maple-look vinyl veneer over MDF, and replace it with real wood to match other cherry in my house.
My first thought for wood was a solid piece of alder that I stain cherry (as I've done on previous projects). However, a co-worker introduced me to a wood store here in Portland (Crosscut) that has an incredible selection. I now plan on buying cherry plywood and using cherry veneer around the edges. I'll leave it natural, of course.
For finishing, I don't have spray equipment, so I'm limited to wipe on or brush on finishes, or something in a spray can. I've already finished projects in polyurethane, so I'd like to try something different. I'm willing to sacrifice durability for a change, especially if it is repairable (I'm actually quite gentle with my desk, just the occational beverage on a coaster).
So I'm thinking of oil or shellac.
BLO seems to be popular with cherry, but having read much of Bob Flexner's book, tung oil seems to be more durable (and smell better). I've also read a post here that shellac over tung oil looks good, so that's an option, too.
Am I on the right track? Has anyone had experience with something besides polyurethane varnish on a cherry desk? Or should I stick with a poly and try oil/shellac on a different project?