I have a bunch of panel glue ups in my future. I was thinking of getting some parallel clamps and giving them a try for gluing the panels. But which brand?
Bessey
Jorgensen
Jet
Woodriver (Woodcraft brand)
None of the above (why?)
Other (please specify)
I have a bunch of panel glue ups in my future. I was thinking of getting some parallel clamps and giving them a try for gluing the panels. But which brand?
Anthony,
I voted for Bessy because that's what I have and therefore use. If I'm not mistaken all the clamps you've listed are K-Body clones and I suspect that they all work pretty much the same.
The K-Body clamp from most of the manufactures appear to be identical but they've added subtle features line removable jaw pads, cushioned handles, feet, variations in bar design, reversible heads etc.
I bought some Bessy clones and did a pretty thorough review.
http://www.woodworkslive.com/index.p...ic,5612.0.html
I have both Besseys and Cabinet Master. I can clamp two pool table balls togeter only with the Besseys, indicating that the jaws on the cabinet master are not really parallel. The amount of error may or msy not make much difference for woodworking, but if you are ever clamping pool table balls together...... Also I find the cabinet master clamps to be too big.
I use Bessey's but the problem that I have from them are after about 2 years there is so much friction in the screw that when I turn the handle when I use them the whole clamp wants to rotate. I have tried to use every kind of lubricant there is but they still want to turn. I have even tried graphite. I called Bessey to see what they use when they are built and the customer support says they don't put anything on them when they are built.
I have a ton of cabinet masters and I love them. Dave, send yours my way if you dump them! These are the only ones I have paid full price for.
I like the trigger of the Jet sometimes so I have a few of those too I bought from a buddy.
When the $20 Bessies hit or the mis-marked Bessie Revos at Farm and Fleet were around (I tried to tell them but they would not listen to me so I just said the heck with it and bought them, again, and again, and again) I bought some of those too.
The best advice I can give is not to limit yourself to one brand once you get above 8-12 parallels. They each have features that work really well for different clamp up situations (for example - sometimes you want Jet's trigger to hold the head stay in place - other times you want that Jorgy free floating head to slide right into place with one hand).
In the end they all work REALLY well.
Glad its my shop I am responsible for - I only have to make me happy.
I did vote, but honestly, I just buy whatever brand is cheapest at the time. I don't see a huge difference in them.
I have the Jet clamps. I got a bunch of them free with some equipment I bought (ended up with 6 of them, I think). The release on them is garbage. You can futz around for days trying to figure out the exact position and angle you must hold everything in order to get it to move. I routinely smash my fingers putting these things away, struggling with the release mechanism.
Other than that, I like them just fine. I personally wouldn't buy them again, though.
I voted other, because that is the only ones I have experience with.
1- I have a bunch of Gross Stabil -- good luck finding those now. Bessey bought the company and killed them. They have nice big non-marring faces, are strong and beefy, and work great. I can still get them here in Ontario, since the local tool store bought up a large part of the remaining inventory, and they still sell them at the local tool shows. The sales mgr there was a fan of them and thought they were actually superior to the Bessey's, and I think he had a point.
2- I also have some Irwin parallel clamps. These are heavy. Heavier than the Gross-Stabil, which were also a touch heavier than the basic Bessey. They have an even larger head, which can be a pro or con depending on your situation. The big difference in these is that they bar is not toothed, so it is easier to clean off any glue spills. These also work well.
"It's Not About You."
I didn't vote because I've only used the Jet. For someone like me who was away from woodworking for many years they are fantastic. Before I got them I'd only used 1970s vintage pipe clamps.
I run the K-bodys. They are lighter in weight which makes it easier for me to maneuver them. When the Revo style came out I picked up a bunch more of the originals at clearance sales.
"A hen is only an egg's way of making another egg".
– Samuel Butler
When I started woodworking, I didn't know squat. I have progressed in 30 years - now I do know squat.
I have Jet, Cabinet Master and K-Body.
I like and use the Cabinet Masters the most, they adjust easier and are heavier then the K-Body or the Jet. The slide easy when I want them to slide and slide easy when I want to adjust them.
The thing I don't like about the K-Body is when I want them to slide they won't and when I don't want them to slide they do.
The Jets are nice and I like the lever to release I also like the handle but they are not has strong as the Cabinet Master.
So I use the Cabinet Masters first, then the Jets and then the K-Body.
I own a lot of the K-body clamps and they work well but have to say I prefer the Stanley brand clamps that I got from the Big Lots deal about a year ago.
I get flat glue-ups every time. I don't with the K-Body clamps. The Stanleys just have a better feel to them.
"Remember back in the day, when things were made by hand, and people took pride in their work?"
- Rick Dale
The Jorgensen clamps, when they came out, had a problem with the heads cracking. Anyone know if this is still a problem.
"Remember back in the day, when things were made by hand, and people took pride in their work?"
- Rick Dale