Seeking knowledgeable assessments of ones creative work is an appreciated exchange of this forum. Comments of positive and negative qualities that are astute and detailed with specific explanation are especially valued. In the master sticky section there is a wonderful document of “rules” for critiques. It's important to emphasize that critiques are directed towards the work without criticism of the individual.
We have some outstandingly talented individuals here whom are so kind to offer brief appraisals that are golden nuggets for aspiring turners. I’m beginning to discover that quite often it is the subtlest of details that can greatly enhance a work. With a lively critique process we all can benefit. A 'master' learns too by teaching and developing abilities to communicate nebulous concepts and tooling skills.
The sticky is worth a look if you haven’t seen it and a revisit if it’s been awhile. I for one would like to begin to use “Critique Requested” in the subject line that clearly opens the formal assessment process. My feeling is that the 'C&C' mention tagged to the end of a post are used for cursory acknowledgments and scant reviews.