Well I for one have never thrown I piece in the garbage, I've thrown more than my share in the smoker with some chicken, ribs or a butt. I don't feel quite so bad about it if I can get something out of it. I thought the first pic looked pretty good, maybe tweak the finial a little but not the garbage. At least save it and have something to make a comparison with in a year or two, or slice it in half and see how consistent your wall thickness is. Just another opinion.
Never go to bed angry, stay up and fight. Its much more fun.