I have recently acquired several of my Grandad's saws--and I'd like to learn how to sharpen them. I've sent a couple of my own out to a service and they've come back seemingly in worse shape than I sent them. There's plenty of discussion of files here, but it's the other things I'm interested in. I'm looking for good equipment, I don't plan on collecting a bunch of it, so I'm really looking for good, solid, and serviceable that I won't be looking to replace. Don't mind spending what's necessary for good stuff, but I'm not looking for pristine. I can work with stuff that needs a little work. All of my saws at the moment are in the 7-12 TPI range if that matters. Can some of you saw guys answer a few questions and perhaps offer a bit of advice on these items:
Jointers:
I think a jointer for hand saws might possibly be unnecessary--one could just run a flat file across the teeth. But if I wanted to get one, I think I've figured out that I want one like this: jointer1.jpg because this second kind here seems to be for two man logging saws jointer2.jpg. Is that right?
I've seen some brass ones and cast ones for handsaws, they all look pretty similar to me, so is it any big deal which brand/kind I get, or is there something other than the first style I should be looking at?
Vises
This is something else I might be able to make from a couple of boards, but I think I'd like to get one. Here I've got a few more questions.
-Does the jaw size really matter? They seem to range from about 8 inches or so on up to 10 or 11 inches in length
-Are the 'economy' or unmarked vises adequate, or should I be looking for a known brand like Disston or Stearns? (others?)
-There's a million different styles, here are three--but there are variants of all these, some that screw to a support instead of clamp, etc. I'll want something that clamps to a bench or table, but there are different styles. The first one here, that clamps and is low to the table makes the most sense to me, but hey, what do I know?
vise1.jpgvise #2, a Disston vise2.jpg seems like it might be a bit wobbly up in the air, but what say you with some experience? And finally, there's this type, which vise3.jpg seems to clamp the saw from over the top instead of underneath--sorry for the small pic, I've borrowed these from various places. BTW, the first example here was unmarked and went for about $80, which hit me as way too much. I'm thinking I should be able to get a nice one in the $25-40 range--reasonable expectation or pipe dream?
Saw Sets
Here again there is a bewildering array of types and styles, but the Stanley 42X seems to be 'the one to get if you're just getting one'. Again, just looking for some advice from those who sharpen already.
Thanks in advance to the many of you who share your collective experience and wisdom!
d