I have rhe Gripper and like it but after reading about the Jessem Stock Guides I'm wondering if that might have been a better investment.
I have rhe Gripper and like it but after reading about the Jessem Stock Guides I'm wondering if that might have been a better investment.
I probably have the equivalent of 3 GR-200's. Seems to be a sort of love-hate relationship on this product, so when I got the itch to try one...I waited until somebody did a "shop cleaning" and got a pair. Liked it, so several months later picked up the 3rd one for very little money. Have at least 3 of the 1/8" legs which are really nice to have. Haven't tried the connector deflector--so no comment there.
I like mine, but use the guard when I can. While they don't get discounted often, they do come up used from time to time.
earl
Seems like the Gripper and the Jessem Stock Guides might be the best of both worlds.
Rod - Thanks for your comments. I'm fairly new to woodworking and have as of late spent a lot of time on safety issues not only with the table saw but other power tools. I'm receptive to any improvements that improve the process. With respect to removing the blade guard from your industrial setting do you think it has just as much to do with legal liability to the company as a safety concern? In other words, if the company sanctioned the removal of any safety device or replaced it with something else wouldn't it increase its liability in the event of an accident and wouldn't that be more of a concern than the welfare of its employees? I'm imagining that if an accident did take place the company would feel more secure offsetting their liability and transferring it to the equipment manufacturer, perhaps more difficult if the equipment was altered. I think this thinking also plays a part in school systems replacing their old table saws with SawStops. Not doing so would've put them in a more precarious legal situation if a student was injured. With regard to accessories like the Grr-Ripper, is it possible that some of its criticisms are based more on this displaced legal responsibility than the effectiveness of the device itself?
Last edited by Steve Mathews; 02-07-2017 at 10:06 AM.
I think you will find that there are lots of ways to get to the same place and you will develop what works for you. I have overhead guards on my saws but every once in a while I find them in the way and then I tend to focus too much on the guard and not enough on the blade. Particularly when ripping a piece that is shorter than the diameter of the blade. I don't like trying to use a stick and pushing the piece all the way beyond the blade and still keep the stick under the guard, especially since the offcut is still sitting right next to the spinning blade and is light enough to perhaps catch and throw. That is where I like the Grripper. I'd rather control both pieces and push them out of the way. You want to place yourself so your arm isn't over the blade as I worry more about that exposure than my hand which is way above and out of the way. I would also argue that one of my best safety devices on a saw is a knee kick kill switch. My Robinson has one that also applies a brake and that is a real comfort when a cut seems to not go right. Hunting for the off can be dangerous too. Dave
Hi Steve, there are 3 possible items a blade guard can address
1) Dust collection, without an over the blade collection method, a large portion of the dust will be in the air. The over blade collection can capture this.
2) Kickback, this occurs when the work piece contacts the back, or top of the blade. A riving knife prevents rear contact, a splitter is almost as effective. The blade "crown" guard covers the top of the blade and prevents wood from contacting the top of the blade.
3) Blade contact injuries, the blade guard prevents almost all of these injuries, safe work practices such as push sticks, feeders etc. prevent the remainder.
SawStop technology only addresses item #3, I'm all in favour of the technology, it's the only significant improvement in North American saws since the guard and splitter some 80 years ago, however it's no substitute for a guard and riving knife, which is why a SawStop saw has them factory supplied.
It's not just the liability issue, it's the safety of the worker. Workers are expensive to train, a company has a lot of money invested in employees and can't afford to have them off work because of something they could have prevented through safety practices. Liability also is an issue, however don't discount the productivity costs. Of course all reasonable employers don't want their employees injured for moral/ethical reasons as well.
The Grr-Ripper is an effective push block, however if you've removed your guard or splitter to use, it's an unsafe approach..........Period.
My Father-in-Law was lucky enough to obtain a cabinet makers apprenticeship in England during the last gasps of the traditional apprenticeships. He was fortunate to have been hired by a large prestigious English firm, and to have benefitted from the education, training and experience.
When he moved to Canada to be a shop manager for a company, in his first week at work he was astounded to see "professional" wood workers using a table saw with a dado blade and no guard to make rebates. That was stopped immediately, and the shaper with a stock feeder was employed because the shaper is built for, and guarded for edge treatments of material.
A competent worker always uses the appropriate machine for the task, evaluating performance and safety for every operation.
regards, Rod.
Last edited by Rod Sheridan; 02-07-2017 at 11:37 AM.
This sums it all up ^^^^^^^.
I don't have the Jessem product, but I do have Board Buddy's, or whatever they are called. I can not use them on things much less than about 5-6". The Grr-Rippers come out and are perfectly safe. IMHO. I would say that those that negatively critique them, probably haven't used them. I could be wrong, I'm just saying.
Just like everything else, make sure they are set up correctly before pushing wood through. Yes, I have shaved off part off a hold down because I rushed. This did not create a dangerous situation.
Oh, I bought the two pack when they had a special. You need two with long boards.