Mark,
In the world of bizzaro coincidences I have to say I was pleasantly surprized by your post. I am in in the early throws of re-doing my home office and had chosen the "Big Sur" table as my office desk!!!
I have seen the Crate and Barrel desk at Vintner's Collective wine bar here in Napa and thought its size and look would be appropriate for the changes I plan.
When we moved into the Napa house we discovered the prior owner was a tug boat captain and his wife had fauxed the walls to resemble water! Well... it was novel for a bit as I am a Marine Consultant but the vast amount of blue has finally taken its toll on me. So I plan on a new paint job and new desk.
The Crate and Barrel table has some pretty deep saw cuts in the underside planks to minimize combined movement and even has some metal flat bar on the underside to "stiffen it". I really don't think white oak needs stiffening, just sharp tools to cut it.
Beautiful "copy".
I'll now be very hesitant to show mine off if I decide to make rather than build.
Curious if you sent the top through a wide sander? Lots of work planing and sanding by hand.
As always, thanks for sharing,
Cheers,
Kent