There have been a number of threads lately dealing with shop heating issues. I have a home which is currently under construction with an 24x44 attached, 4-car garage with 10 foot ceilings. Half of it will be my shop. It will be well insulated.
Here's my dilema. I had planned to install in-floor heat in the garage until I got the bid. I have since decided not to do it for a couple of reasons:
1) Cost... The house will be heated with forced air and the basement floor and portions of the first floor will be "warmed" with hydronic heat. That could be done using a beefier water heater for the house that would have a transfer plate to draw off heat for the hydronic system. The additional load on the system to add the garage would require significant upgrades (including a boiler) that added $10 - $15K to the cost of my HVAC system. I'm planning to check with another HVAC contractorto get another opinion/design but I can't afford that much $$$.
2) I am not planning to keep the garage/shop heated continuously due to the utility costs associated. Heating with a hydronic system, I'm told, would take quite a long time to get the area from cold winter temps to a comfortable working temp. I want to turn on the heat and have it warm up quickly.
Instead, I am considering a forced-air unit heater (like a Hot-Dawg) or an infrared heater. Either would be operated by natural gas. In addition, I want to install a wood stove to provide supplemental heat and save fuel costs and as a way to dispose of scraps and mistakes.
I have read other threads which contained comments cautioning people on using infrared heaters because they become uncomfortable to work around. (Like working under a broiler...) I can confirm this to a degree because the hockey rink has one of these and when I sit under it for too long my forehead gets 'sun-burned'. The advantage, however, is they heat the objects in the room (cast iron and concrete) which will radiate the heat into the room. In my mind, this offers some of the advantages of an in-slab hydronic system. I still plan to install insulation under the concrete. A disadvantage of forced air systems is they blow dust around.
In my last place, I had a 15KW electric, forced-air furnace hanging from the ceiling. It was a salvage item... It heated the space well. I had installed filters on it so it doubled as an air-cleaner. I wonder if I could buy a small, cheap furnace and use it as an air-cleaner as I had before. I could maybe install an AC coil in it to cool the place during the summer too. Could I use the same compressor that operates the house AC or would I need a separate unit?
Any thoughts or suggestions? Please consider where I live in Wisconsin when offering advice. Winter temps here are generally close to zero and frequently stay below zero for extended periods during January and February. In other parts of the country (possibly where you live) winter temps may be more mild. This translates into lower BTU loads on the system and lower costs for both the system as well as the energy to operate it.
-Kevin