My local Ace had thier 20% off anything in the Bag sale last Saturday and I bought a 'red' can of Minwax Anitque Oil. Used it last night for the first time on a dyed piece of maple. First reaction is I like it slightly better than the Watco.
Antique oil is definately thicker and you can tell it has more resin than the Watco. I noticed the sweating you get from Watco for several hours after applying was much less with the Antique oil. 'Sweating' is the shiney spots that seem to wipe off for as much as 8 hours after applying the oil.
Here is my procedure:
Apply the oil with paper towel.
Wait for the slightest dry patch to show, ussually only a few minnutes. Reapply with new paper towel.
Repeat the wait and wipe on again cycle for at least 30 or 40 minutes.
Wipe dry throughly with paper towel.
Remove from chuck and take in the house.
Wipe off 'sweat' every time I walk by for the next several hours.
Several days later reverse to turn the bottom and give the whole piece another coat or two.
Am I doing it right?
Frank