Thanks for the help Bob, I suspect that I've inadvertently work hardened the blade?? I also wondered if the small anvil I was using had too small a surface area, (4" x 6").
Either way, its disappointing to think I ruined the D12--that was the nicest flea market Disston I have found. Good info on the blade thickness comparison--I noticed that the blade was thinner than my D-8's but I didn't how much thinner the D12 was--particularly in comparison to the Warranted Superiors, (just my luck the two that I have are straight!)
I've learned a ton from these articles and appreciate your insights very much. I keep a printed copy of your filing and restoration articles with my sharpening files and jigs for quick access. They have helped me resurrect several old gems!
Again thanks
Glen