Which is better... expanding chuck jaws into a dovetailed recess, or contracting around a spigot?
The SuperNova2 instructions seem to indicate the expansion into a recess is better - at least the listed maximum size of the bowl is larger for expansion mode than for contraction mode.
That seemed counter-intuitive to me.
Now that I've done some bowls both ways, with 50mm and 100mm jaws, it seems to me that contraction mode gives a stronger grip. At least I feel like I've had more bowls come out of the jaws in the expansion mode.
Forming a cleanly cut recess seems a bit more difficult than forming a spigot (tenon) - unless there's a trick or technique I'm missing out on.
Plus it's harder to accurately judge the bottom thickness with a recess. (DAMHIKT.)
OTOH, my wife (and head-critic-in-charge) really prefers the looks/lines of the recessed tenon/foot.
What's the consensus on this forum regarding the advantages/disadvantages of these two fixin' methods?