Help me choose a chair front... (pics now)

[Walt Caza]

Hi Everyone,
This poll is a companion to the Great Morris Chair project.
Well, I had to screw up to learn again, but here is the stretcher poll promised here (link)
http://www.sawmillcreek.org/showthread.php?t=85886
In the specific post by me entitled 'stretcher decision'.


I have now added a pair of pics of the parts in question. sorry
And thanks for your input,
Walt

[Ed Sallee]

Walt, I like the one on the bottom.....

[Leo Zick]

option E: send to me, they wont work for you

[Walt Caza]

Just a quick update:
The majority voted for the bottom board to become front stretcher of my chair.
I wiped a bit of mineral spirits on to help show the grain.
I lost most of the sunray pattern cutting it down to size, but here it is...
front-stretcher.jpg

What remains of the thumbprint board after dimensioning, became back stretcher.
back-stretcher.jpg

These pattern were much better when the boards were larger. Shucks!
But more lessons learned...how else can you get them?!?

Thanks to all who voted...me I voted to burn them both!
take care,
Walt