So my Lee Valley order from Berea arrived at the office today (errrr... don't ask). I'm kicking myself for not ordering the twin-screw when I had the chance, but that's another story...
For the record, I'm a Stanley bigot - search my posts to confirm. I enjoy the hunt, I enjoy the restoration, I enjoy tuning to perfection, and I enjoy the nostalgia when using them. I bought a LN #4 several years back because it looked like a Stanley...
Though I've never publically poo-poo'd the new fangled Veritas planes, I've never been too smitten with the looks. They don't look like Stanleys - they've all been "improved!" Bleh! I have, however, publically strutted, bragged, and boasted that I can tune an old Stanley to perform just as well as these new premium planes. I've stood side by side with Marcus against the best of them!
Yes, Lee Valley is a great company, Rob Lee is a fine man, etc, etc. I've gotten quite a bit of this and that from them over the years. I just don't like their new fangled, high falutin' planes... If I ever wanted another premium plane, I'll buy a LN (since they look right).
But with that said, I picked up a Veritas Bevel-up Smoother (BUS) when I was in Berea - mainly to confirm my ... err ... thoughts that there was nothing more than a lot of hype and celebrity to these planes.
I was wrong.
Now hear me folks, I had a LN #4 that was perfect. Tissue paper, newspaper print, sub thou kinda perfect. And I have several Stanleys that can compete with it. But this BUS is... well... it's just a wholly different animal. In Berea, on a whim, I just happened to pick it up to give me some credibility in supporting my assumption (ignorance). I rolled it over in my hands - Norrisy adjuster - ha! Short, stubby iron - ha! Twisty knob - poo! Set screws - Silly! Low and wide - joke! Funky looking to boot - figures!
I set that thing to wood... And I had to buy it. Can't explain it really...
Anyhow - to make short story much longer... My first - errr - few Lee Valley planes came today. I spent about 10 minutes with the BUS. Man, that thing is a strange beast. (I know I'm probably a few years late - bear with me - I'm obligated ). The iron is short and stubby, but Lord, that thing is thick. I'm sure you can finds specs and all, I'm just telling you - it's thick; I thought they'd messed up an sent me some crazy Japanese iron. Secondarily, I have some 20+ Hock irons, and several Lie-Nielsen irons. I found some paper in the shipping that said that LV irons are lapped to blah, blah, blah. "Yea, right" says I. "I buy the best blades in the business, and they ain't nowhere close to fully lapped." Uh - this first blade I grabbed was lapped - uh - like perfectly lapped. I went right to the 8000 Shapton and had a perfect polish in 2 minutes. Insanity. Honed up the blade... thought I'd give it a shot.
The frog - uh - "machined area" of the iron bed seemed to be just as big as the iron. Seemed well machined to me (I'm the emotional reviewer, nothing whatsoever to do with measurable data!). I didn't read the instructions, but kinda figured out how to move things around. Still not a big fan of the adjuster - the whole "put the little pin in the little hole" is probably easy enough for a monkey, but I've not evolved quite that far. Projected the blade, twisted this and that to close the mouth and started taking shavings...
Fellas - I'm a Stanley bigot. They are my favorite planes - by far. I'm not a Lee Valley fan boy by any stretch. I'm an traditionalist - Disston and Stanley for me, and I reserve the right to poo-poo funky saws, new fangled planes, and $300 block planes in velvet socks. But I have to tell you (Marcus, sorry my friend...), everyone who works wood owes it to him\herself to try this plane - and I say that with all the sincerity I can muster. It's a strange beast, but what I could do with this 50 degree blade was quite amazing. I take sub-thou shavings at will, but pushing this smoother, I continually chuckled and said, "Wow." I've taken mountains of shavings with many different planes I've tuned to be "super smoothers," but after just a few shavings with this plane, it just felt very different; like a ... "real smoother," a "super duper smoother?" And I'm not sure how else to explain that - low center of gravity, mass, blah, blah. (Go search for Cohen, the difference in review quality and IQ will be readily apparent! ).
I don't know where they sell them locally, or where you can try them - but this Stanley bigot will never give up his BUS... (as much as it pains me to say that!). Yes, I was wrong...
On the negative side, a brass nut on the tote was loose... So there...
My apologies to my Stanley cohorts; I felt obligated to post...
Respectfully,
- jbd in Denver