Consumer Cellular

[roger wiegand]

Consumer Cellular resells service from AT&T and T-Mobile, as does Mint. There's no reason to think that there would be any speed or coverage differences as they are reselling the same service. If those networks are strong where you need to use your phone then you should be fine. They are both non-existent where I live, and Verizon isn't much better.

Tracphone, now owned by Verizon, mostly uses the Verizon network and is converting users to that system.

[Jim Becker]

Roger brings up a good point. Check with your friends about what carriers they use and see if you can have them come to your home to look at signal levels for each. All of the entities like Consumer Cellular use the "big" carrier's networks, so understanding what network or networks have good coverage where you live will help you choose a new carrier (or stay with the one you have).

There are some more basic phones available out there and entities like Consumer Cellular tend to make their availability easier than the big carriers do since a healthy part of their market is "mature adults". Samsung and Motorola both have "modern" flip phones in their lineup, BTW.

[Tom Stenzel]

With Tracfone there is no way to make calls when you're out of the country. The amount of data for their smartphone plans is pretty meager if you go with the cheap 'refills'.

Lately if you go to the store you get a card and tell the cashier what plan you want. The card has on it that there's a $20 plan, a $25 plan, $35 plan and so on. You tell the cashier what plan you want. Nowhere on the card or any store display are you told what you get with these different plans. They currently have two different $25 plans. How do you distinguish between them to the cashier? It's infuriating. The only reason I can figure they do this is to force customers to an autopay system. To me that defeats the idea of a no contract phone.

I get the $25 60 day plan which is more than enough for the yakkin' I do on the phone. The minutes and texts roll over so now I'm down to my last 6,000 minutes and 11,200 texts or so. I'm still considering jumping ship from them.

-Tom

[Curt Harms]

Consumer Cellular resells service from AT&T and T-Mobile, as does Mint. There's no reason to think that there would be any speed or coverage differences as they are reselling the same service. If those networks are strong where you need to use your phone then you should be fine. They are both non-existent where I live, and Verizon isn't much better.

Tracphone, now owned by Verizon, mostly uses the Verizon network and is converting users to that system.

Doesn't Mint use T Mobile? I thought that's what I read. Mint is a great deal, especially if you use quite a bit of data.

[Terry Wawro]

We've been using Consumer Cellular for around 8 or 9 years now. Not the absolute cheapest but the plans are reasonable and the customer service is great.

[Brian Elfert]

A big part of the problem for the OP is probably because he is still using 3G. Verizon is certainly not investing any money in their 3G network and may very well be moving some of their 3G spectrum to 4G or even 5G service at this point. A new 4G LTE phone may work just fine with Verizon.

That said, Consumer Cellular will work just fine if only doing voice calls. I bet Verizon is not cheap for just voice,

[Curt Harms]

I've read where carriers have been trying to shut 3G down for some time but keep delaying. A problem is that a lot of cellular alarm systems are 3G only so have to be replaced, there is apparently no upgrade path. There has been resistance to that.

[Jim Becker]

Brian, VZ has been actively shutting down 3G for some time now. Same for ATT, and TMo is in currently process of shutting down the old Sprint 3G, too. (there 3G shutdowns are wreaking havoc with vehicle telemetry and remote communication subscriptions, but that's a different topic) I agree with you that the OP shouldn't assume that VZ coverage under 4G will be equally bad. That was kinda the reason I suggested that he get a few friends "in house" that have service on the various carriers to see how things look with the more current technology.