I always try to be supportive of peoples work and their designs...that is usually very easy, because there is some extermely fine workmanship and design by SMC members. It is always a pleasure to see this. Occasionally I see a design that has poor proportions or its "overdesigned" IMHO and I often refrain from comment completely or I talk about the workmanship and refrain from coments about the design... I think people are sensitive to what they designed and these ideas came from in their head....it is delicate... I never want to discourage new original work even if its not great. If I say "it could have been better if...." and its already built....not good If someone is using a screwdriver to square a mortise...he is usually not offended if you tell him a chisel works better....but design...oooohhh.....what should I say